Files
gitmost/apps/server/test/integration/search-lookup-explain.int-spec.ts
T
agent_coder f794ac6d6c fix(search): оживить trgm-индекс — убрать coalesce из LIKE-предикатов (#443, ревью)
Ревьюер поймал EXPLAIN'ом: lookup-query фильтровал по
LOWER(f_unaccent(coalesce(col,''))), а GIN-trgm-индексы — на coalesce-free
LOWER(f_unaccent(col)). Postgres берёт функциональный индекс только при точном
совпадении выражения, так что обёртка coalesce отключала индекс → Seq Scan по
pages на КАЖДЫЙ lookup (MCP-клиент всегда шлёт substring:true). Зелёный
int-гейт это не ловил (проверял корректность на крошечном датасете, не
использование индекса).

- search.service.ts: убрал coalesce из двух index-driving LIKE-предикатов
  (title + text_content). Семантически эквивалентно: NULL LIKE '%q%' = NULL
  (falsy), NULL-страница просто не матчится — как пустая строка не матчит %q%.
  SELECT/ORDER BY оставлены с coalesce (индекс не выбирают, Node гардит NULL).
- Миграция: убран избыточный ре-ассерт idx_pages_title_trgm — его создаёт #348
  на том же coalesce-free выражении, теперь title-предикат его использует.
  idx_pages_text_content_trgm без изменений (уже coalesce-free), поправлены
  вводящие в заблуждение комментарии. down() дропает только text-индекс.
- Новый тест search-lookup-explain.int-spec.ts (3): title→idx_pages_title_trgm,
  text→idx_pages_text_content_trgm (оба ассертят отсутствие Seq Scan on pages),
  + негативный контроль (coalesce-обёртка не может использовать индекс) против
  тихой ре-регрессии. Дискриминатор enable_seqscan=off.
- CHANGELOG: две записи (opt-in substring lookup mode + смена shape MCP search).

EXPLAIN на реальном PG: обе fixed-ветки → Bitmap Index Scan on trgm; buggy
coalesce → Seq Scan (Disabled:true). Гейт: server jest src/core/search 27/27
(16 исходных int без изменений + 3 EXPLAIN + 8 unit), mcp node --test 708/708,
tsc чисто.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-07-10 21:57:16 +03:00

124 lines
4.6 KiB
TypeScript

import { randomUUID } from 'node:crypto';
import { Kysely, sql } from 'kysely';
import {
getTestDb,
destroyTestDb,
createWorkspace,
createSpace,
} from './db';
/**
* #443 dead-index guard — EXPLAIN on the REAL DB.
*
* The lookup mode's substring predicates run a leading-wildcard
* `LOWER(f_unaccent(col)) LIKE '%q%'`. Those are only fast when Postgres uses
* the GIN trigram indexes:
* - idx_pages_title_trgm on (LOWER(f_unaccent(title))) [#348]
* - idx_pages_text_content_trgm on (LOWER(f_unaccent(text_content))) [#443]
*
* Postgres uses a functional index ONLY when the query expression matches the
* index expression EXACTLY. The original lookup query wrapped the columns in
* `coalesce(col,'')`, which differs from the coalesce-FREE index expression and
* silently forced a Seq Scan on pages for EVERY lookup (the MCP client always
* sends substring:true). This test locks that in.
*
* Discriminator: `SET enable_seqscan = off` asks the planner "CAN this predicate
* use the index at all?" — which is exactly what the coalesce bug breaks. With
* seqscan disabled:
* - the coalesce-FREE (fixed) predicate plans a Bitmap Index Scan on the trgm
* index (no Seq Scan on pages);
* - the coalesce-WRAPPED (buggy) predicate cannot use the index and falls back
* to a Seq Scan on pages even though seqscan is disabled.
* We assert both to prove the fix and to keep the regression from silently
* returning.
*/
describe('SearchService agent-lookup EXPLAIN — trgm index is live [integration]', () => {
let db: Kysely<any>;
let workspaceId: string;
let spaceId: string;
async function insertPage(title: string, textContent: string): Promise<void> {
const id = randomUUID();
await db
.insertInto('pages')
.values({
id,
slugId: `slug-${id.slice(0, 12)}`,
title,
textContent,
spaceId,
workspaceId,
})
.execute();
}
// Run EXPLAIN (no ANALYZE — we only inspect the chosen plan) and return the
// concatenated plan text.
async function explain(query: string): Promise<string> {
const rows = await sql<{ 'QUERY PLAN': string }>`EXPLAIN ${sql.raw(query)}`.execute(
db,
);
return (rows.rows as any[]).map((r) => r['QUERY PLAN']).join('\n');
}
beforeAll(async () => {
db = getTestDb();
workspaceId = (await createWorkspace(db)).id;
spaceId = (await createSpace(db, workspaceId)).id;
// Seed enough rows that a trigram index is a plausible plan. The content is
// varied so the '%needle%' pattern is selective.
for (let i = 0; i < 200; i++) {
await insertPage(
`seed-title-${i}`,
`seed body content number ${i} lorem ipsum dolor sit amet ${i}`,
);
}
await insertPage('backup-srv.local', 'the needle-token-xyz lives here');
// Keep the trgm indexes' stats fresh so the planner costs them correctly.
await sql`ANALYZE pages`.execute(db);
});
afterAll(async () => {
await destroyTestDb();
});
// Force the planner to answer "can the index be used?" rather than "is it
// cheaper than a seq scan on this size?". Restored after each test.
beforeEach(async () => {
await sql`SET enable_seqscan = off`.execute(db);
});
afterEach(async () => {
await sql`RESET enable_seqscan`.execute(db);
});
it('title predicate (coalesce-FREE, as fixed) uses idx_pages_title_trgm, not a Seq Scan', async () => {
const plan = await explain(
`SELECT id FROM pages WHERE LOWER(f_unaccent(title)) LIKE '%srv.local%'`,
);
expect(plan).toContain('idx_pages_title_trgm');
expect(plan).not.toMatch(/Seq Scan on pages/i);
});
it('text_content predicate (coalesce-FREE, as fixed) uses idx_pages_text_content_trgm, not a Seq Scan', async () => {
const plan = await explain(
`SELECT id FROM pages WHERE LOWER(f_unaccent(text_content)) LIKE '%needle-token%'`,
);
expect(plan).toContain('idx_pages_text_content_trgm');
expect(plan).not.toMatch(/Seq Scan on pages/i);
});
// Negative control: the OLD coalesce-wrapped predicate must NOT be able to use
// the index — even with seqscan disabled it can only Seq Scan pages. If this
// ever stops seq-scanning, the coalesce/index expressions have re-aligned and
// the guard above is no longer meaningful.
it('coalesce-WRAPPED text predicate (the bug) cannot use the index — falls to Seq Scan', async () => {
const plan = await explain(
`SELECT id FROM pages WHERE LOWER(f_unaccent(coalesce(text_content,''))) LIKE '%needle-token%'`,
);
expect(plan).not.toContain('idx_pages_text_content_trgm');
expect(plan).toMatch(/Seq Scan on pages/i);
});
});