A 10-agent red-team pass on the two-way Docmost<->git sync surfaced 16 ranked
findings (9 others triaged out as already-defended). Wrote a reproduction test
per finding (each asserts the CORRECT behavior, so it fails on the bug), then
fixed the production code so every repro goes green. All confirmed bugs:
Round-trip data loss (markdown-converter.ts + docmost-schema.ts mirror):
- #1 editor-ext node types silently dropped on export — ported the 8 missing
canon nodes (footnoteReference/footnotesList/footnoteDefinition, htmlEmbed,
status, pageEmbed, transclusionSource/Reference) into the git-sync schema
mirror and added converter cases that emit their schema-matching HTML instead
of flattening unknown nodes to '' (this was the critical data-loss flagged in
review #1679: footnotes/htmlEmbed lost on sync). Snapshot surface updated.
- #2 top-level image lost width/height/align/attachmentId — now emits an HTML
<img> (like video/diagrams) when it carries layout attrs; bare images stay
. Image node parses width/height as strings so they re-import.
- #3 code block containing a ``` fence corrupted on round-trip — outer fence is
now widened to (longest-inner-backtick-run + 1).
- #16 deep nesting threw RangeError (page never synced) — added a depth guard
(MAX_NODE_DEPTH=400) so the converter never overflows the stack.
Push/layout/cycle (engine):
- #4 disambiguation ' ~slugId' suffix corrupted Docmost titles + order-dependent
layout — deterministic, order-independent sibling disambiguation; suffix is
stripped from a path-derived title ONLY when the new name is exactly the old
title plus the suffix (never a genuine retitle ending in ' ~token').
- #6 retry-adopt by (parent,title) clobbered the wrong duplicate-title sibling —
ambiguous (parent,title) is no longer adopted (falls back to fresh create).
- #12 a new child under a new parent was created at ROOT — creates are ordered
parent-before-child with an in-memory created-id map for parent resolution.
- #13 git conflict markers could reach Docmost — bodies are scanned and the
marker lines stripped (a '=======' line is only treated as a conflict
separator inside a <<<<<<< ... >>>>>>> block, so setext headings are safe).
- #15 a divergent `docmost` mirror was escalated by runPush but dropped by
runCycle — RunCycleResult now forwards divergentDocmost to the orchestrator.
Server (merge / lock / provenance):
- #9 3-way merge lost a human's block edit when git inserted an adjacent block —
finer-grained diff3 region merge (via lcs) preserves non-overlapping human
edits; genuine same-block conflicts still resolve git-wins.
- #10 single-writer race — module-static liveLocks closes the same-process TOCTOU
window, and a heartbeat refresh that cannot confirm the lock now aborts the
cycle at its next write checkpoint (cooperative AbortSignal threaded through
runCycle). Cross-process fencing tokens remain a follow-up.
- #14 sticky-agent provenance overrode an explicit actor='git-sync' write,
blinding the listener loop-guard — resolveSource now lets an explicit actor
win over the sticky-agent fallback (explicit agent still wins).
Verified: git-sync vitest 617 pass (+1 expected-fail), server unit jest 1541
pass, server tsc clean. A review pass over the fixes caught and corrected a
title-suffix over-strip, an inert abort signal, a document-wide conflict-marker
strip, and two leaf-atom content-holes.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Resolve the code-review findings from comment #1571 on PR #119.
Engine (packages/git-sync):
- Idempotent CREATE on retry: before createPage, look the page up in the
live Docmost tree by (parentPageId, title) and ADOPT it instead of
duplicating when a prior cycle created it but failed to persist the
pageId back to disk. Only trust a COMPLETE tree for the lookup; fall
back to createPage otherwise. Covered by new tests incl. a complete=false
regression-lock.
- Route applyPullActions diagnostics through an injected logger instead of
bare console (thread log from the cycle).
- Add a timeout to the git execFile chokepoint (runRaw) so a hung git
subprocess cannot wedge a sync cycle.
- Translate remaining Russian code comments to English.
- Remove dead standalone-CLI code (parseArgs/PushParsedArgs,
parseSettings/envSchema, loadSettingsOrExit + config-errors.ts) and the
matching index exports/specs; keep the Settings type.
- Fix the dangling docs link in package.json.
- Add a schema-surface snapshot guard so any drift in the vendored
document schema is a loud, must-review CI failure (+ provenance header).
Server (apps/server):
- Add a configurable watchdog timeout to the spawned git http-backend so a
stalled push cannot hold the per-space lock forever
(GIT_SYNC_BACKEND_TIMEOUT_MS).
- Close the in-process TOCTOU window in SpaceLockService.withSpaceLock by
reserving the slot synchronously before acquire.
- Add tests: removePage git-sync provenance (both branches), ensureServable
force-push-protection git configs, and the phase-B+ datasource methods.
Docs / build:
- AGENTS.md: list git-sync as the fifth workspace package and note the
three schema mirrors; fix the dangling git-sync-plan.md backlog link.
- pnpm-lock.yaml: add the missing @docmost/git-sync workspace link so
pnpm install --frozen-lockfile (CI default) succeeds.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Closes the architecture item from the #119 review: drop the "vendored from
docmost-sync" framing and the CJS↔ESM `Function('import()')` bridge so the engine
is a normal first-class gitmost package.
Part 1 — vendoring markers removed (prose only, zero behavior change): reworded
"VENDORED into gitmost" / "vendored from docmost-sync" / "Engine LOGIC is
byte-identical" / "it's a port" comments across the engine. Behavior-bearing
strings are untouched: BOT_AUTHOR_NAME/EMAIL and the `Docmost-Sync-Source:`
provenance trailers (changing them would break git authorship + the loop-guard).
Part 2 — the package is now ESM (matching the sibling @docmost/mcp): `type: module`,
tsconfig Node16, `.js` extensions on relative imports, and a static
`import { marked }` replacing the `new Function('return import(...)')` /
`loadMarked` hack — the bridge is GONE from the package. The CommonJS NestJS
server loads the now-ESM engine via a new `git-sync.loader.ts` that mirrors the
existing `docmost-client.loader.ts` mcp loader exactly (Function-indirected
dynamic import + cached promise + retry-on-reject). The 4 server consumers
(orchestrator/datasource/vault-registry/git-http-backend) call `await loadGitSync()`
for value exports; types stay `import type` (erased). The converter-gate spec —
which needs the real converter — loads the package's TS source via a jest
moduleNameMapper + isolatedModules (documented in that spec); the other git-sync
specs mock the loader.
Verified: engine builds pure ESM (no Function/require leftover), vitest 614,
editor-ext build, server + client tsc, full server jest 1397/0. Live stand
smoke-test: server starts clean on the ESM engine (no ERR_REQUIRE_ESM), a real
sync cycle runs through the loader, and the basic e2e suite is 12/12 (clone via
git-http-backend, push, pull, delete, 3-way merge — all through the new loader).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Self-review of phase 3 caught a data-corruption regression: nativeMeta always
supplies the run's spaceId, so the planner's 'create-without-spaceId' skip — which
had doubled as the only filter for non-page files — went dead. An ADDED
.obsidian/*.json, attachment, or dotfile (committed to the vault, no .gitignore)
would then be classified as a CREATE: a junk Docmost page, plus a gitmost_id
frontmatter written INTO the file, corrupting it.
Fix: isPageFile(path) — a .md file with NO dot-segment anywhere — and filter the
diff to page files at the very top of computePushActions, BEFORE any
classification, so non-page A/M/D/R are ignored (design §Адопция). 2 unit tests
pin it (.obsidian/json, attachment, dotfile, dot-segment, .md dotfile all ignored;
real pages still created). 614 engine tests green.
Also: refreshed stale docmost:meta comments to gitmost_id (review SUGGESTION), and
documented the deferred adoption frontmatter-preservation gap (review WARNING) in
page-file.ts + the design doc (do NOT roll native onto a real vault with Obsidian
properties until phase 4 round-trips them).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Per owner: test data, no migration. parsePageFile no longer reads the old
docmost:meta block — a file without a gitmost_id frontmatter is simply un-tracked
(adopt). Vaults are a cache: rm -rf on the transition, rebuilt native from
Docmost. Simplifies the format work (no fallback). Doc updated.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Pivot the thin-meta design to "the vault IS a native Obsidian vault": clean
markdown + a minimal YAML frontmatter `gitmost_id:` (the durable pageId, travels
with the file so identity survives any move); folders mirror the page tree with
the parent's body as a folder-note `<Folder>/<Folder>.md` (LostPaul Folder Notes
convention); links as `[[wikilinks]]` (basename-resolved → reparent never breaks a
link, only retitle does); collisions disambiguated Obsidian-style; `.obsidian/`
and non-page files left untouched (no .gitignore). Verified the conventions
against the Obsidian/Folder-Notes docs.
Replaces the abandoned `.gitmost/index.json` sidecar (path-keyed → fragile to
git-undetected renames; the in-file id is self-sufficient): removes vault-index.ts.
Adds lib/page-file.ts — parsePageFile/serializePageFile (frontmatter id + clean
body) with a LEGACY `docmost:meta` fallback for migration. 6 unit tests; engine
suite green. Not yet wired into pull/push — no behavior change. Design doc
rewritten to the native-Obsidian format.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The implementation spec docs/git-sync-plan.md was removed as completed, but ~44
code comments still cited it as "plan §N". Strip those citations (comments only),
keeping each comment grammatical. The vendored engine's own "SPEC §N" references
point at a different, still-present spec and are left untouched.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Coder↔reviewer design loop (9 rounds, reviewer verdict: exhaustive) produced
92 specs; implemented +123 tests (465 -> 588 passing). The new round-trip
coverage exposed three genuine data-loss bugs in the Markdown<->ProseMirror
converter, all now FIXED (round-trip is lossless for these):
1. pageBreak was lost on export (no converter case -> rendered to "" and the
node vanished). Now emits <div data-type="pageBreak"></div>, which the schema
parses back -> round-trips.
2. A block image between blocks left an empty <p> artifact after import-hoisting,
producing a phantom blank-gap diff on every sync. markdownToProseMirror now
strips content-less paragraphs after generateJSON — with a schema-validity
guard that keeps the obligatory single empty paragraph in `content: "block+"`
containers (tableCell/tableHeader/blockquote/column/callout/doc), so empty
cells/quotes never become an invalid `content: []`.
3. The `code` mark combined with another mark was not byte-stable (emitted nested
HTML that the schema's `code` `excludes:"_"` collapsed on import). The
converter now emits code-only when `code` co-occurs, matching the editor.
New coverage spans media/diagram/details/columns/math/mention attribute
round-trips, converter emission branches, git error paths, and engine decision
branches. A dedicated test pins the empty-container schema validity (the review
catch on the bug-2 fix).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Make @docmost/git-sync natively consumable by the CommonJS server (and jest):
build to CommonJS (tsconfig module CommonJS, drop type:module, strip .js from
relative imports), and lazy-load the only ESM-only dep (marked) via the dynamic
Function('import()') trick (mirrors docmost-client.loader.ts) with a require()
fallback so vitest's evaluator works too. git-sync tests stay green (314 pass,
3 expected fail).
Add the §13.1 idempotency gate (apps/server .../git-sync-converter-gate.spec.ts):
13 editor-ext docs (paragraphs/headings, marks, links, bullet/ordered/task lists,
blockquote, callouts, code block, hr, table, nested mix) round-trip
content(editor-ext) -> convertProseMirrorToMarkdown -> markdownToProseMirror ->
TiptapTransformer.toYdoc/fromYdoc(tiptapExtensions) -> canonicalize and assert
docsCanonicallyEqual. All green => the vendored converter's docmost-schema is
schema-compatible with editor-ext (no node/mark/attr loss), which the plan §13.1
requires before Phase B. The one intrinsic markdown-image lossiness (width/height
/align can't ride plain ) is isolated in a KNOWN DIVERGENCE block, not
hidden. Server tsc clean.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
First step of docs/git-sync-plan.md. New workspace package @docmost/git-sync
vendoring the PURE parts from docmost-sync (HEAD b03eb35):
- lib: markdown-converter, markdown-document, canonicalize, docmost-schema,
node-ops, diff, and an extracted markdown-to-prosemirror (only the pure
marked->HTML->generateJSON path from upstream collaboration.ts; no websocket).
- engine (pure, no IO): reconcile, layout, sanitize, stabilize, loop-guard.
Ported the upstream pure-module + round-trip corpus tests (vitest): 314 pass,
3 expected upstream known-limitation fails. tsc clean. No server wiring yet.
docmost-schema inlines getStyleProperty (as packages/mcp does — @tiptap/core
3.20.4 doesn't export it). IO engine (pull/push/git/settings) deferred to later
Phase A/B steps; the editor-ext idempotency gate (plan §13.1) is the next step.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
